Image Credit: Inspec Inc. | KEYENCE | Cannon Water Technology Inc.
Indicators and comparators are instruments for comparative measurements where the linear movement of a precision spindle is amplified and displayed on a dial or digital display. Indicators utilize electronic, mechanical or pneumatic technology in the amplification process; e.g., dial indicators, digital indicators and electronic amplifiers or columns. These gaging amplifiers or instruments are available in three main types:
1) Comparators or high precision amplifiers (including columns or electronic amplifiers).
2) Indicators (higher precision compared to test indicators, used for inspection).
3) Test indicators (lowest precision, widely applied in production checking).
Different Kinds of Comparators
Mechanical comparators, electronic comparators, or appliers and pneumatic or air comparators are gaging devices for comparative measurements where the linear movement of a precision spindle is amplified and displayed on a dial / analog amplifier, column, or digital display. Mechanical comparators have sophisticated, low friction mechanism, better discrimination (~0.00001"), and lower range (~+/- 0.0005") compared to compared to indicators. Comparators have a higher level of precision and less span error compared to conventional dial or digital indicators. The level or precision is sufficient for measurement of high precision ground parts and for the calibration of other gages.
What are Indicators?
Indicators are gaging devices for comparative measurements where the linear movement of a spindle or plunger is amplified and displayed on a dial, column or digital display. Typically, indicators have a lower discrimination (~0.001" to 0.0001") and greater range (~+/- 1.000" to +/- 0.050" total) compared to comparators. The level or precision is sufficient for final part inspection.
Video Credit: Starrett
Why are Test Indicators Different?
Test indicators have the lowest discrimination when compared with indicators and comparators. Test indicators used mainly for set up and comparative production part checking. Test indicators often use a cantilevered stylus or level style probe that facilitates inspection of hard to reach part features, but results in high cosine errors. A cosine error of 0.0006" may result over a travel range of 0.010". Test indicators are not considered absolute measuring instruments, but comparative tools for checking components against a standard or zeroing-out setups.
Other devices that fall within the category of indicators and comparators include gage sets, gaging stations and gaging systems.
A-A-2348 - INDICATORS, DIAL, ACCESSORIES AND TEST SETS
A-A-59006 - INDICATORS, PIPELINE, FLOW, SIGHT
BS EN ISO 8503-1 - PREPARATION OF STEEL SUBSTRATES BEFORE APPLICATION OF PAINTS AND RELATED PRODUCTS - SURFACE ROUGHNESS CHARACTERISTICS OF BLAST-CLEANED STEEL SUBSTRATES PART 1: SPECIFICATIONS AND DEFINITIONS FOR ISO SURFACE PROFILE COMPARATORS FOR THE ASSESSMENT
DIN EN ISO 8503-2 - PREPARATION OF STEEL SUBSTRATES BEFORE APPLICATION OF PAINTS AND RELATED PRODUCTS - SURFACE ROUGHNESS CHARACTERISTICS OF BLAST-CLEANED STEEL SUBSTRATES - PART 2: METHOD FOR THE GRADING OF SURFACE PROFILE OF ABRASIVE BLAST-CLEANED STEEL - COMPARATOR
Related Products & Services
Bore and ID Gages
Bore and ID gages are designed for internal diameter dimensional measurement or assessment.
Calipers typically use a precise slide movement for inside, outside, depth or step measurements. Some caliper types are used for comparing or transferring dimensions.
Depth gages are used to measure of the depth of holes, cavities, or other component features.
Gage blocks are manufactured to precise gagemaker tolerance grades for calibrating, checking, and setting fixed and comparative gages.
Height gages are used for measuring the height of components or product features.
Micrometers are instruments for precision dimensional gaging consisting of a ground spindle and anvil mounted in a C-shaped steel frame. Noncontact laser micrometers are also available.
Snap gages are used in production settings where specific diametrical or thickness measurements must be repeated frequently with precision and accuracy.