Case Study No. 13 – Fluoride Ion Monitoring in Drinking Water and Water Applications (or non Acid/Etching Wastewater)
Online Fluoride Ion Monitoring for Water Districts and other Water Authorities
- Simple to use inline fluoride ion monitoring system operates just as easily as any inline low flow pH system
- Reliable menu driven Industrial Ion Selective Analyzer calibrates, displays, outputs and controls all in fluoride ppm units
- Inline fluoride ion sensor is completely sealed from both sides and requires no chemical addition -- unlike many popular competing sampling fluoride analyzers
The Problem
A water district was required to monitor the levels of fluoride in the city drinking water supply. If the levels were too low, fluoride was required to be added. If fluoride levels were too high, fluoride must be removed. Because of the natural temperature variance at the measurement point, the existing sampling fluoride analyzer gave erratic results. The constant requirement of adding reagents to the sampling analyzer placed a high burden on the busy maintenance staff, and resulted in reduced plant efficiency. When the problems with the sampling fluoride analyzer could not be addressed, grab sample analysis was used. The use of constant grab sample during times of problems with the online equipment created an undue burden on the maintenance staff, and defeated the purpose of having an online fluoride monitoring system.
Since multiple measurement points were required, a complex system of piping was installed to deliver sample to the few sampling analyzer available. One a few sampling analyzer were installed due to their prohibitively high cost. This caused the two fold problem of a delay in the measurement due to the piping of the sample to the analyzer (not real time) and the centralization cause the entire system to go down at once when problems occurred with any of the few analyzers that were installed.
The Solution
An inline fluoride ion selective sensor, specially engineered to water and wastewater application was chosen, with a rugged fluoride mono-crystal ion sensing element, and a virtually maintenance solid state reference system. In order to optimize the stability of the inline fluoride sensor measurement, a low flow sample bypass system was employed. A menu driven, simple to use, industrial ion selective transmitter and analyzer that was capable of calibrating, displaying, outputting and controlling in ppm units was selected. A convenient bayonet style twist lock inline installation style was selected for its ease of removal, facilitating the required calibration and cleaning. Calibration solutions were formulated that were ten fold (one decade) apart in value and would bracket the target concentration range. The calibration solutions were designed to closely mimic the expected ionic background of the measured solution. The calibration system simplified the validation of the online fluoride analysis system and reduced the need for grab sample calibration all while replacing the cumbersome sampling fluoride analyzer.
The Fluoride Sensor Used:
Model: AB 8100-100-10 Fluoride Ion Selective Sensor
Description: 1" MNPT Twist Lock (Quick Disconnect) ULTEM Bodied Fluoride Ion Selective Sensor; Integrated 100 Ohm Platinum Temperature Element; 10 feet cable to connect directly to Rosemount 54e-ISE Analyzer/Transmitter/Controller
Case Study No. 7 – Total Ammonia Analysis in Wastewater
Total Ammonia Determination through online ammonium ion and pH monitoring
- Industrial grade ammonium ion selective membrane and application engineered solid state conductive polymer reference can withstand the rigors of industrial process lines
- Ammonium calibration system has been optimized to yield reproducible results in a variety of wastewater systems
- Ammonia gas resistant pH sensor delivers the accuracy needed for total ammonia computation via a PLC or DCS from the ammonium ion and pH input values
The Problem
A sweetener manufacturer wanted to control the total nitrogen content in their process. This was a difficult proposition since they had a mixture of dissolved ammonia gas and ionized ammonium ions in solution. Fluctuation of process pH did not allow for a simple mathematical correction or computation, and made real time control arduous. The complex process solution necessitated significant interaction between ASTI and the customer to develop the proper custom calibration solutions. The total nitrogen must be calculated based upon an equation whose variables are pH and ammonium activity. Creating an accurate calibration system is a challenge in a complex system, whose primary function is not to determine simple activity, but rather a computed or derived total concentration. Common TISAB (total ionic strength adjustment buffer) solutions are often inadequate ISE standards for industrial calibrations because they do not accurately reflect the ionic strength and pH of the process solution. This application then necessitated not only determining the proper multi-point calibration for both pH and ammonia/ammonium, but also developing an interactive curve and standard ion buffer background which accurately reflected the process. Getting agreement and consistency between laboratory titrations and on-line measurement or process values was accomplished by using custom calibration solutions as the common reference standard for both the laboratory and process measurements.
The Solution
The solution was a ammonia gas resistant pH sensor and an industrial grade organic polymer ammonium ion selective sensor. Both the pH and ammonia sensor were sealed against any dissolved ammonia gas which may attack the reference element at lower pH. The reference element was designed to be insensitive to the interferences experienced by the ammonium polymer membrane. The ammonium ion analyzer, in combination with the PLC, was capable of computing the total nitrogen concentration via a multi-parameter algorithm. The multi-point calibration developed for this application allowed the PLC to create an accurate curve at any point along the operating pH range. The total ammonium analysis system was able to deliver reproducible and accurate results, replacing slow and inaccurate grab sample laboratory analysis.
The Ammonium Ion Sensor Used:
Model: AB 6410-873DPX-25 Ammonium Ion Sensor
Description: ¾"- 1" MNPT Immersion ULTEM Bodied Ammonium Ion Selective Sensor with integrated 100 Ohm Platinum Temperature Element, Stainless Steel Solution Ground and Foxboro 873DPX compatible preamplifier; 25 feet cable to connect directly to Foxboro 873DPX (Dual Channel Auto pH Compensation) pH/ISE Analyzer/Transmitter
The pH Sensor Used:
Model: PNA 6031-873DPX-25 pH Sensor
Description:¾"- 1" MNPT Immersion ULTEM Bodied Dissolved Ammonia Gas Resistant General Purpose pH Sensor with integrated 100 Ohm Platinum Temperature Element, Stainless Steel Solution Ground and Foxboro 873DPX compatible preamplifier; 25 feet cable to connect directly to Foxboro 873DPX (Dual Channel) pH/ISE Analyzer/Transmitter
Case Study No. 15 – Sodium & Calcium Ion Analysis for Water Softener Systems
Calcium (Ca++), Magnesium (Mg++) & Sodium (Na+) Ion Analysis
- Before and After Water Softener to determine Water Quality Feed to Boilers
- Industrial grade sodium ion selective membrane and application engineered solid state conductive polymer reference can withstand the rigors of industrial process lines
- Sodium calibration system has been optimized to yield reproducible results in a variety of boiler water systems
The Problem
A company wanted to automate the water quality testing on their water softener used to feed their boilers. When the softener ceased to function properly, the water softener needed to be regenerated. A delay in this service may cause damage to the boilers, eventually leading to a shutdown to clean and repair the boilers. The existing manual sampling routine or online sampling analyzers were slow and expensive, respectively. In addition, the delay caused by not having an accurate real-time online method to determine the effectiveness of the water softener could cause hard water to spread throughout the plant, leading to operational difficulties.
The Solution
ASTI's online ion selective sensors can be used to measure the effectiveness and state of the water softening system, although this measurement must be performed indirectly. The customer indicated a desire to measure the activity of calcium (Ca++) ion at a point after the water softening system. This measurement is not feasible due to the degree of excess of sodium present. The permissible ratio of excess of sodium (interfering) ion to calcium (analyte) ion for our calcium ion selective sensors is 100 fold (on a molar basis), whereas the lab analysis revealed an excess of 2600 fold (also computed on a molar basis). This then indicates that the concentration of sodium is 26 times too high to perform the calcium measurement after the water softener. ASTI found an excellent and feasible method to indirectly measure calcium after the softener and determine the effectiveness of the softening system as a whole. .
Typical Concentrations Before Softener
Sodium - Na+ = ~ 48 ppm
Calcium - Ca++ = ~ 160-250 ppm.
Typical Concentrations After Softener
Sodium - Na+ = ~ 300 ppm
Calcium - Ca++ = ~0.200-0.600 ppm.
The ion exchange system is clearly replacing calcium ions with sodium ions. If the ion exchange system fails or deteriorates, the sodium ion activity at the post softener location is changed from about 300 ppm to about 48 ppm. This is almost a step change in concentration. Measurement of such a change is an appropriate use of an inline ion selective sensor. At the post softener position, all concentrations of interfering ions for the sodium ion selective sensor are within the permissible range. The sodium ion activity as measured prior to the water softener can provide a valuable baseline sodium ion (Na+) level. The magnesium ion (Mg++) contribution to water hardness is ignored because it will be also be converted to sodium ion, which will be analyzed at the after softener measurement position. In addition, the concentration of magnesium is often five to ten (5-10) times less than calcium and usually occurs at a fixed ratio to calcium.
When the softener is functioning properly, the sodium ion (Na+) levels as measured after the softener will be quite high (~300 ppm), corresponding to a lack of calcium ion (Ca++) in the softened water (see abbreviated water analysis above). When the softener fails to work properly, the sodium ion levels at the post softener measurement point will return to the low levels as measured at the before softener measurement point (~30-50 ppm). This provides a very simple method to use the ion selective system as an alarm and indicator as to the state of the water softening system. In addition, the ion selective analyzer can automatically switch the water (via a relay) to a functioning secondary water softening system to avoid any downtime. A Rosemount 54e industrial sodium ion selective analyzer was employed to conveniently calibrate and operate in familiar ppm units. This ion selective analyzer had the necessary 4-20 mA outputs (scaled in ppm) and relays (also set in ppm) to enable the automation of this implicit water hardness (Ca++ & Mg++) determination for water quality analysis of the water softening system.
The Industrial Sodium Ion Selective Sensor Used:
Model: AB 8430-100-10 Industrial Sodium Ion Selective Sensor
Description: 1" MNPT Twist Lock Quick Disconnect ULTEM Bodied Industrial Sodium Ion Selective Sensor with integrated 100 Ohm Platinum Temperature Element; 10 feet cable to connect directly to Rosemount 54e Ion Selective (ISE) Analyzer and Transmitter
Choosing the Correct pH/ORP Sensor
1. Choose a sensor body type that suits the physical parameters of the installation (refer to the Configurations Portion of pH/ORP and Ion Selective webpages).
2. Choose a sensor that suits the process application, temperature, chemistry, and physical parameters of the installation (refer to Sensor Selection Guides and call factory or local sales agent for support)
3. Choose a sensor housing material that is compatible with the process chemistry, temperature & pressure (refer to Chemical Resistance Charts as posted under the Technical Documents portion of the website).
4. Select suitable temperature compensation element, solution ground & integrated preamplifier based upon the mating pH/ORP Instrument (refer to Electrochemical Instrumentation Page & ask for factory support).
5. Specify the required cable length based upon installation location (refer to Part Numbering Guide).
* Subject to application qualification and review by an approved ASTI sales agent and/or factory. Performance guarantee is posted on the ASTI online application questionnaire page.
** See list of supported pH/ORP/ISE Instruments webpages as posted on the ASTI website.
*** Completion of Application Questionnaire form is required. Other restrictions may apply.
Organic Membrane Ion Selective (ISE) Sensors
• Tetrafluoro Borate (BF4+)
• Hydronium (H3O+ - pH)
• Primary Amines (R-NH3+ Cl-)
• Ammonium (NH4+)
• Barium (Ba+2)
• Calcium (Ca+2)
• Carbonate (CO-3)
• Cesium (Cs+)
• Chloride (Cl-)
• Lithium (Li+)
• Magnesium (Mg+2)
• Nitrate (NO3-)
• Nitrite (NO2-)
• Potassium (K+)
• Perchlorate (ClO4-)
• Silver (Ag+)
• Sodium (Na+)
Solid State Ion Selective (ISE) Sensors
• Bromide (Br-)
• Chloride (Cl-)
• Cyanide (CN-)
• Fluoride (F-)
• Iodide (I-)
• Silver (Ag+)
• Sulfide (S-)
• Thiocyanate (SCN-)