Eliciting and Analyzing Expert Judgment: A Practical Guide

In this book we provide guidance on how to gather and analyze expert judgment. The need for such a source has been great, particularly for those who are lay persons in the area of expert judgment. We have met many people working in the physical sciences, in government, or in the military who were struggling to elicit or analyze expert judgment. Their jobs required that they perform these tasks, but the information available to assist them was scarce. This book is our response to their special needs. We describe elicitation and analysis procedures, when to use them, and how to perform them in a way that allows lay readers to design methods suited to their own particular application. Additionally, we have designed this book so that the reader can start at any chapter, depending on his or her special needs. Those more experienced with expert judgment, typically those working in the fields of risk analysis, reliability analysis, operations research, decision analysis, or knowledge acquisition, may also find the book of interest because in it are mentioned techniques and options that could extend or improve their usual methods.
In this chapter we introduce expert judgment and its use in varied situations. We define expert judgment as it will be covered in this book and provide an overview of the methods that will be presented for eliciting and analyzing...