Web Site Usability: A Designer's Guide

Part II: Site Scrapbook

Chapter List

Chapter 9: Edmund's
Chapter 10: Hewlett Packard
Chapter 11: WebSaver
Chapter 12: Travelocity
Chapter 13: Inc.
Chapter 14: Cnet
Chapter 15: Fidelity
Chapter 16: Disney

This section gives you a guided tour of the sites we studied, beginning with the site that scored best (Edmund's) and continuing down the rankings.

There's one exception: The Olympic site, which finished second in our study, was taken down before we got any pictures. Although we tried contacting the creator of the web site, we couldn't gain access to it.

The Edmund's site (www.edmunds.com) is a resource for consumers who want to research and purchase cars and trucks. This is a "shovelware" site: It contains all the content from Edmund's printed publications and then some.

The success of the Edmund's site surprised us. The site is mostly text, with no graphic design. Users rated this site highly for its authoritativeness and quality of information, and they successfully used it to find information.

We believe the success of this site has to do with its long, descriptive links, which help users predict where they will go and what information they will find there. Edmund's also does a good job of providing cross-links to related content. The site does lack a search facility. This caused one user to give up.

Table 9.1: We used these questions to test the Edmund's site.

Question Type

Example Question

Simple Fact

Can you get a new Honda Accord for under $15,000?

Comparison of Facts

Which truck has the...

UNLIMITED FREE
ACCESS
TO THE WORLD'S BEST IDEAS

SUBMIT
Already a GlobalSpec user? Log in.

This is embarrasing...

An error occurred while processing the form. Please try again in a few minutes.

Customize Your GlobalSpec Experience

Category: Online Communities
Finish!
Privacy Policy

This is embarrasing...

An error occurred while processing the form. Please try again in a few minutes.